On the Basis of Sex

In June of 2020, SCOTUS handed down a ruling in Bostock v. Clayton County, which has presented some questions as to how far the freedoms under Title VII actually reach.

Bostock, in brief, held that Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 does protect employees against discrimination based on their sexual orientation or gender identity.

Title VII notes that: “It shall be an unlawful employment practice for an employment agency to fail or refuse to refer for employment, or otherwise to discriminate against, any individual because of his race, color, religion, sex, or national origin, or to classify or refer for employment any individual on the basis of his race, color, religion, sex, or national origin.”

The Bostock ruling defined that this basis of sex did include sexual orientation and gender identity because discrimination on those employed was related directly to sex.

Gerald Bostock was working for the department of social services in Georgia when he joined a gay softball league. Following this, he received criticism at work and inappropriate remarks from coworkers. Shortly thereafter, Bostock was fired for “conduct unbecoming of an employee.” Bostock filed a complaint with the EEOC and then three years later filed a lawsuit based on Title VII of the Civil Rights Act.

The Supreme Court ruled in a 6-3 decision that firing an employee based on their sexual orientation or gender identity was a violation of the Civil Rights Act. Bostock was consolidated with two similar cases, Altitude Express v. Zarda and R.G. & G.R. Harris Funeral Homes v. EEOC and Aimee Stephens. The court in Bostock said that discrimination on the basis of sexuality or transgender status required an employer to intentionally treat an employee different because of their sexual preferences.

The court did acknowledge that in 1964, when Title VII was drafted, this issue would have not been considered, but the majority opinion did not give any value to the legislative history of the act. This was one of the main divergences between the opinions of the majority and dissent.

You can read the full opinion at: https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/19pdf/17-1618_hfci.pdf.

~Katherine N. Fuller

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Exploring Elements of Civil Causes of Action

Tecklenburg Amanda Image Elements of Civil Causes of ActionElements of Civil Causes of Action, by Michael G. Sullivan and Douglas S. MacGregor, is the South Carolina civil practitioner’s go-to guide for research. Published by the South Carolina Bar, the fifth edition includes definitions and elements of 50 of South Carolina’s most common civil causes of action.

Each cause of action is listed in alphabetical order, by chapter. This concise formatting makes it an easy and quick method to research any general question, saving you hours of research time. Each chapter breaks down and defines the cause of action into its component parts. The chapters also include a discussion of defenses and remedies. Additionally, the book is heavily annotated with citations to controlling authority, including cases and statutes.

Where do I get my copy?

This book is so helpful that the CSOL library has updated our collection with each new edition. The library has copies of the second, third, fourth and fifth editions. There are two copies of the fifth edition—the most recent edition from 2015—on class reserve.

This book is also available on the South Carolina Bar’s website for purchase for $95. The book also comes with a CD containing sample pleadings for certain causes of action. The price is well worth the handy material. A successful attorney recently told me she uses her copy so often her cover has fallen off.

For students, the best option to access the book may be online. LexisAdvance has the book available on its database. It is even one of the “top sources” of secondary material in the South Carolina collection.

Why you should use this resource

 Just recently, I used this book to help me draft a complaint for premises liability. Elements of Civil Causes of Action gave me a good starting point to allege each element in my complaint. I was very thankful to have it as a resource, and I hope that this blog post will help a fellow student with their assignments one day.

Written by:  Amanda Tecklenburg

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Exploring Oxford Constitutional Law

The Oxford Constitutional Law research database serves as an excellent resource for any student, practicing attorney, or general academic with a curiosity and passion for understanding the history, theories, and intricacies behind Constitutions, and the questions that inevitably come up in their enforcement.

This database, which is owned and run by Oxford University (and accessible through the Charleston School of Law library), includes the institution’s three constitutional law services: Oxford Constitutions of the World, US Constitutional Law, and the Max Planck Encyclopedia of Constitutional Law. Each of these services provides a different look into constitutional law, and though the types of materials offered are the same for each, the contents themselves are extremely varied, giving the researcher access to a comprehensive and diverse collection of documents to view.

Having all of their products in one location, Oxford has created a database that allows the user to pull up a myriad of information available in one location, while still allowing the researcher to narrow the search to the product of their choosing. This lends itself to a research platform that is very inclusive and thorough, and yet still extremely easy to navigate.

The types of content offered by Oxford Constitutional Law include the following:

  • Constitutional instruments and materials
  • National instruments and materials
  • Commentary and analysis

The Constitutional instruments and materials contain actual Constitutions (national, sub-national, and indigenous) from all around the world, as well as amendments that have been made to them and related documents that may have been influential in their formation (for example, the United States’ Declaration of Independence). The amount of information contained here is truly impressive; in fact, this is the only resource that contains English language versions of every constitution in the world.

The National Instruments and materials consist of different national legislation from around the globe that is related to that country’s or state’s respective Constitution, such as laws passed to clarify a provision or to expound upon a certain subject. This provides for even more context surrounding not only the history of the document, but the ways in which its provisions have been interpreted and debated throughout time.

ox1

An example of what a Search looks like on Oxford Constitutional Law

The third type of content available on Oxford Constitutional Law is commentary and analysis. This section consists of mainly what would be considered secondary sources, and includes information in the following forms:

  • Book content
  • Encyclopedias
  • Bibliographies
  • Constitutional overview (by jurisdiction)
  • Notes
  • Chronologies

These resources offer information focusing on different constitutional law subjects, the histories behind the Constitutions themselves, and various pieces that attempt to clarify common issues that have been frequently raised in this area. They also offer analyses and comparisons of Constitutions throughout the world, to provide true perspective to the study as a whole.

The final component of the Oxford Constitutional Law database is the Oxford Law Citator. This tool allows the user to search for a subject, case, piece of legislation, etc., and then provides them with a citation for a piece of legal information, other documents that cite or mention what is being searched, or links to full text within the Oxford Law system and across the web. The Oxford Law Citator is a fast and easy way to find a wide variety of credible resource related to the subject of your choosing.

ox2

The home page of the Oxford Law Citator

The Oxford Constitutional Law database is a great resource for anyone involved in the history and study of constitutional law as a whole. As far as practice goes, this resource is very limited in its scope, and though it offers numerous and varied in depth pieces of information, those looking for more primary sources and more general information may not gain much from its use. However, the material is routinely updated and contains solid primary information, as well as credible secondary sources verified courtesy of the Oxford Law Citator.

For those devoted to the study and for the academics with great interest in that area, Oxford Constitutional Law is a must have. The material is routinely updated and contains solid primary information, as well as credible secondary sources verified courtesy of the Oxford Law Citator.

Written by: Jack Jackson

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Simplify your research by owning a copy of South Carolina Family Law Annotated

FamilyFrom marriage, divorce, blended families and family assets, family law is a constantly evolving area of the law, being up to date on the law is crucial to effectively helping your clients. Published by Thomson Reuters, South Carolina Family Law Annotated (“SCFLA”) is the one stop guide to South Carolina Family Law. Not only does it consist of the relevant statutes and cases, but also provides the family court rules, South Carolina Constitution and alternative dispute resolution rules and procedures.

In my opinion, the SCFLA is a great resources for attorneys, mediators and judges alike. It provides relevant statutes along with the pertinent cases that accompany them. It has brief descriptions of the most relevant cases with citations to more specific cases that may guide your research. The SCFLA provides a quick and concise reference for anyone practicing in the realm of family law.

This resource also contains West Key Number System to be able to reference other related cases when doing research. The SCFLA would be useful for law students who are studying family law or doing research on how South Carolina has applied their family law statutes.

This book contains information on:

  • Divorces
  • Child custody
  • Visitation
  • Adoptions
  • Asset distribution
  • Guardianship of disabled adults
  • Qualifications and requirements for marriage
  • Name changes
  • Estate related matters

It is organized by the way the statutes appear in the South Carolina Code, and has a very in-depth index that helps to guide you to the exact information that you need. If I were practicing family law this would be a welcome, and necessary, addition to my library.

The SCFLA is published annually and is available for purchase on Thomas Reuters Website for $311. It is also available for a monthly subscription through their site for $24 a month. The benefit to the subscription is that it is updated with the new information and new editions as they are published. Additionally, if you have access to the Charleston School of Law Library there is the 2009-2019 editions of the SCFLA located in the South Carolina Practice Materials.

Written by: Katherine Fuller

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

South Carolina Requests to Charge—Criminal

SCCriminalThe South Carolina Requests to Charge—Criminal, Second Edition provides general jury instructions as well as criminal charges and defenses to those charges. In a criminal trial, after closing arguments, the court charges the jury, meaning the court gives the jury their instructions and definitions of law that relate to their specific case.

When lawyers provide the court their jury charges, it allows them to guide what they want from the jury during deliberations. To do this attorneys can provide the judge tailored law as it pertains to facts of the case. Defense attorneys should provide the proper defenses including their definitions. This is crucial to provide a zealous defense. The judge makes the final call on what instructions the jury takes with them into the deliberation room.

This source gives easy to understand lay term instructions and definitions about criminal law that lawyers can use as a guide in writing their instructions for the jury. Jury instructions are one of the most important parts of the trial because these documents are taken with the jury when they go deliberate.

To provide a clear and easy understanding of the law for the jury can win or lose a case. The jury must first understand the law in order to apply it. Like many jurisdictions, South Carolina prohibits jurors from taking notes during the trial and therefore, jury instructions are among the only written materials that go into the deliberation room when they make their determinations.

In 2010, the South Carolina General Assembly passed the Omnibus Crime Act which abolished many common law offenses and instead incorporated statutory offenses. This source provides an easy understanding of the new statutory law put into place by the Omnibus Crime Act and its definitions, as well as the applicable South Carolina code sections to each charge and governing cases in the state.

An interesting addition to the law is the common law offense of  “lynching” superseded by statute as “assault and battery by a mob.”

The resource includes:

  • General instructions
  • Definitions of offenses
    • sex offenses
    • drugs offenses
  • Confessions
  • Defenses

This supplement is for sale by the South Carolina bar for $125. Each hardcover text sold includes the entire text on a CD. The CD format allows for easy searching and faster research when in a crunch. Although the most recent version was published in 2012, it is a great resource for any attorney planning on practicing criminal law in the state of South Carolina.

Written by:  Estafany Foracker

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

American Maritime Cases: From Stem to Stern

boatIn the technology driven, “I know what I want and I want it now” quicker more than ever, world that we live in, a subscription to the American Maritime Cases (“AMC”) online database is a no brainer for U.S. maritime attorneys. For admiralty and maritime subject matter, AMC provides everything, including the galley sink.

The Charleston School of Law (CSOL) is one of only three law schools in the U.S. that offers a Maritime and Admiralty L.L.M. As such, CSOL has a subscription providing all of their students with access to the print and online resource.  Availability to the AMC database can be found on the Charleston School of Law Library website under databases. There is a quick-link called “Library Databases” that will take you to a catalog of all the database links of which CSOL has access. AMC is under the Admiralty & Maritime Law heading. Clicking on the link will take you to the online database where you can research cases that involve everything from ship wrecks, like that of the Golden Ray (pictured above), to maritime liens. 

American Maritime Cases (AMC) has been a comprehensive print, and now online, resource for researching significant maritime decisions by U.S. federal and state courts since 1923. AMC also reports legislative action, administrative law and arbitration decisions, Canadian and other international cases, as well as other significant items.  The eight editors are based in AMC’s office in Baltimore, MD. They are experienced maritime attorneys who are responsible for case selection, headnote drafting and key AMC policy decisions.

The major benefit of AMC is that it includes practically all U.S. maritime cases covering a myriad of maritime subject matter. Covering everything from maritime salvage, maritime lien priority, punitive damages, etc., an AMC subscription is a must have for maritime practitioners. Moreover, an annual online subscription that cost $475 is much more affordable that the four and five figure Westlaw and Lexis subscriptions.

AMC’s copyrighted indexing system provides maritime attorneys with a subscription prime access to admiralty and maritime laws most comprehensive research tool. In this day and age practitioners and law school students alike are relying more and more on digital resources to conduct their research. AMC is kept current up to practically the present day. For quick access, there is a column on the right-hand side of the home page where one can find the most recent decided cases that are under review for publication.

On AMC’s homepage, there is a link that takes one to a page that highlights all the topics and subject matter covered:

  1. Click “Latest Issue” link
  2. Click on subject matter of interest (i.e. “salvage”)
  3. Click page number hyperlink associated with topic

Additionally, once on the latest issue page, to more quickly access topics:

  • Click “Headnotes/Principal Topic List”
  • For Advanced Search:
    • Click “Search Cases”
    • In Search bar type:
      • various information to find cases of interest

Admiralty and Maritime attorneys will find this resource very valuable as the editors work hard by continuously updating the database which provides a thorough, accurate, and balanced resource that will prove indispensable in the technical and complex area of the law.

Written by:
Landon Brock
Juris Doctor Candidate, 2020
Maritime Law Society: Vice President
Maritime Law Bulletin: Brief Editor

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Everything about Animal Law: Animal Law Resource Center

Biggs Brittany Image pet laws iconAnimal Law Resource Center is an advocacy website with the goal to provide access to legislation and legal matters pertaining to animals and the law. The electronic resource is a project of the National Anti-Vivisection Society (NAVS). NAVS is a not for profit organization and dedicated to advancing science without harming animals that operates out of Chicago, IL.

Animal law impacts criminal law, contracts, torts, sales, and professional licensing. Information on the website includes animal cruelty, laboratory animal welfare, wildlife management, and other animal related issues. The electronic source is free and does not require a person to register for use of the resources. Animal Law Resource Center can be accessed at http://www.animallaw.com/. The website can also be accessed through the Charleston School of Law Sol Blatt Jr. Law Library under the Free Internet Portal.

Chicago area interns update the website regularly. The website states it is a searchable database intended to help legal professionals, students, advocates, and the general public. Animal Law Resource Center utilizes information from State and Federal Websites and provides direct access to pending legislation and current laws.

On the website’s homepage there are links for:

  • Laws
  • Legislation
  • Case Law
  • Bibliography
  • Model Laws
  • Take Action
  • Donate

The Laws tab provides statutes that can be narrowed to focus on federal or state material, categories, and parameters. The law section would be beneficial for the general public, law students, and practicing attorneys since it does redirect to the actual statute for the topic related to your search.

The Legislation tab allows you to click on a state to see the status of bills under that state. You can click on the bill number and this will redirect you to a different website that tracks the status of that bill, track.govhawk.com. I believe congress.gov would be a more reliable resource to check the status of bills.

The Case Law tab provides an insight on how judges interpret laws regarding animals. However, the case link does not redirect to the actual case and does not include if there are issues with the case. I would not recommend this section for law students or practicing attorneys to utilize for information or citing.

The Bibliography tab includes searches for articles and books on specific topics of animal law. The sources provided in the search are not linked to another resource.  This is not beneficial since you would have to go through the same style of search within another resource after utilizing this search.

The Model Law tab provides suggested language that can serve as a template for drafting legislation. The topics provide model laws, additional commentary, and sources utilized by Chicago Law School advocates. These resources can be beneficial for research and may lead to other sources.

Under the Take Acton tab there are two options. The Animal Advocacy Center provides Federal Legislation, State Legislation, and National Issues. The weekly newsletter provides updates on legal and legislative developments for animal advocates, the general public interested in animal law, or students and attorneys who are involved in animal law to guide you towards beneficial research that might affect your area of interest or practice.

The Learn More tab includes more information pertaining to the Animal Law Resource Center and what the resource aims to accomplish. This section would be a good quick review and help when beginning searching certain areas of animal law if you are not familiar with the topic of animal law.

Overall, the Animal Law Resource Center would be a good resource for the general public that would not have access to other electronic resource websites. However, I would not recommend this site for law students or attorneys practicing in animal law unless it was for a starting point in research. I believe this site could help narrow down areas of law to search pertaining to your topic.

Some of the links and information are not connected to authoritative information. The resource could lead to other secondary sources that would be beneficial and lead to authoritative information, but I would recommend double checking this information and making sure that it is the most updated information and still relevant. This could cause an extra step in research for law students and practicing attorneys that may not be the most efficient and effective use of time.

Written by: Brittany Biggs

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

GALE PRIMARY SOURCES: U.S. Declassified Documents Online

classified1U.S. Declassified Documents Online is an online database that provides researchers with an uncanny view of declassified documents generated by United States governmental agencies. This highly engaging resource, compiled by Gale Primary Resources for the purpose of legal and historic research, has contributions from multiple governmental agencies speaking to a wide array of classified, secret, and top secret topics in unredacted detail.

The collection, according to Gale resources, is the most comprehensive collection of declassified documents from the executive branch. Materials in U.S Declassified Documents Online Include: Intelligence studies, policy papers, diplomatic correspondence, cabinet meeting minutes, briefing materials, and domestic surveillance and military reports.

The collection editors have actively monitored the release of formerly classified documents from presidential libraries. They have also added numerous major releases of declassified documents from the Department of State, Department of Defense, Central Intelligence Agency, Federal Bureau of Investigation, Joint Chiefs of Staff, and other executive agencies.

This resource is free to students at The Charleston School of Law and is available on the Library database catalogue; the breadth of information provided by this database is enormous and the sensitive nature of the material makes this resource both highly engaging and interesting!

Written by: Dillon Calhoun Biering, J.D. Candidate

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Legal Research Consists of more than Looking up Cases

Law_comIf you are looking for a website that allows you to embrace new information while having fun, then the website, Law.com, is perfect for you. This website encompasses a vast variety of information. In producing so much information it is easy for students to become overwhelmed by the influx of information. This website produces a different affect. Law.com is organized in a way that allows its users to access information easily so that they do not become lost during the search process. I found that navigating the tools of this database came with great ease.

Law.com is a fairly new database. Since the data base is so new, it adheres more closely to the needs of the modern day attorney and law student. It was founded by Bill Carter in 1998 shortly after he created its parent company, American Lawyer Media (ALM) in 1997. This database may be accessed for free by Charleston School of Law students. The following link will direct you to the Charleston School of Law’s Sol. Blatt Jr. Law Library database. You will find the Law.com link on that page.

Law.com Includes:

  • Law firm information and statistics
  • Community Group Interests
  • Law Firm Surveys & Rankings
  • Job Database
  • Law Dictionary
  • Verdict Search Tool
  • News Publications

This database is one that is useful to both attorneys and law students. The law dictionary is a tool that will likely be the most useful for both parties. The  law dictionary sites do more than just define the word or phrase in a simplistic bare bones manner. It also gives you specific contexts in which the word is used in everyday legal jargon.

This database dedicates a specific category of its website to law students. This category may be found under the “Communities” tab. This section of the website serves not only as a source of information but also as a source of entertainment. It encompasses articles that the drafters of the website feel most closely relate to Law students.

In browsing the website, you will find that its information is one that reaches beyond the borders of the United States and allows you to broaden your search to legal information and news that is presented internationally as well.

If a student is looking to receive the most up to date information, this website will serve the student well. The articles produced by this database are updated daily to provide new ideas and insight as they pertain to the legal field. Furthermore, the website gives its readers access to several topical news publications.

In conclusion, this database will serve any student with an interest in current events and law wells. It allows one to explore legal research beyond its traditional case law searches.

Written by: Kelly Barber, Class of 2020

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Criminal Offenses in South Carolina

SC_CriminalCriminal Offenses in South Carolina is a print legal resource published by Thomson Reuters. The most current edition is Criminal Offenses in South Carolina, 3d, 2019-2020 edition. This is a single volume treatise which is useful for students, researchers, and practitioners alike. The book gives the detailed elements of crimes in South Carolina in a well-laid out, easy to read format. Although the book focuses on criminal offenses, it also notes when certain offenses are also misdemeanors.

 

About the Author

This resource is authored by John R. Ferguson. Ferguson received his undergraduate degree from Duke University and his juris doctor from the University of South Carolina. He has been practicing law for over 30 years. He is a partner at Cox, Ferguson & Wham, LLC in Laurens, South Carolina. Ferguson is open to suggestions and insights about the content of the book and what additions and corrections should be made in future updates.

Organization

The overall structure of the volume consists of a table of contents, the substance of the material covered, followed by an appendix.  The book is organized into chapters covering groups of related crimes and misdemeanors. Each chapter is divided into sections which delve into the specific felonies and misdemeanors related to the broad chapter topic. For example, there are chapters titled Crimes Against Property, Crimes Against the Person, and Drug and Alcohol Offenses, among others. The sectional breakdown of the chapter on Drug and Alcohol Offenses includes sections titled Drug trafficking, trafficking in methamphetamine or cocaine base, and distribution, purchase and manufacture of methamphetamine.

The appendix is broken down into four sections which provide a few more useful ways of navigating the book. Appendix A is an alphabetical list of criminal offenses included in the book. The Table of Laws and Rules provides statutes and rules referenced in the material. The Table of Cases gives a list of the sample cases used throughout the text given to illustrate the pertinent law or rule. Finally, the index provides an alphabetical listing of groups of related offenses.

Why use this Resource

As mentioned above, this resource has a broad range of uses from students learning the rules to researchers and practitioners leveraging the resource for research starting points and practice guidelines, respectively. For the student, the resource provides an easy to digest format of statutory laws and rules of criminal law in South Carolina. For the researcher, this treatise provides a starting point for researching criminal laws and provides sample cases and annotations from South Carolina courts that can be used as a starting point to expound on their research.

This book is also useful when used in conjunction with other secondary sources such as legal encyclopedias. Lastly, for the practitioner, this book is an almost indispensable quick-reference guide to navigating laws and rules in the criminal law landscape in South Carolina. It also provides guidelines on sentencing, penalties for crimes, possible defenses, and cross-references to both related common law and related statutory offenses.

Pricing

There are two options to get this resource. The 1,234 page current version can be had for a flat price of $440.00 from Thomson Reuters. This price includes the only the current version and no updates. There is also a monthly pricing option. For a fixed monthly price of about $37.00, the book and all updates, revisions, and new editions can be had. This option also allows the choice of a 24, 36, 60, or 120 month term for the monthly pricing.

Written by: Karl Baker

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment